You wonder at some people. I enjoyed Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials trilogy so, as a sort of instinct I thought only good of the man. Then, a few days ago he was interviewed in a National Sunday, dissing Winnie the Pooh and Wind in the Willows. Utterly unwarranted and exposes the inane arseholey in the man.
And then again AA Milne, author of Winnie the Pooh, famously dissed PG Wodehouse in a spat covering many years and that, too is unforgivable. The creator of Bertie Wooster cannot be treated thus.
What Wodehouse did in return was to accuse Milne of exploiting his son, the eponymous Christopher Robin, for financial gain and self aggrandisement. He wrote the same into a story and Milne, humourless to the last never forgave him.
Which is one of the themes of my latest cinematographical experience, GoodBye Christopher Robin.
This is a good film, taking its start point when AA and his wife think Christopher Robin has been killed in action during WW2. We then back track to Milne Senior after WW1 and him trying to cope with the aftermath, the recurrent horrors. How bees terrified him, as reminders of the flies on the corpses in the trenches, or an exploding balloon taking him back to nightmarish bombardments. He is portrayed as an ardent pacifist throughout though history suggests that was on the wane by the end of the 1930s.
His wife, all brittle self control apparently masking a crippling lack of self confidence, is characterised as the driving force behind both Milne writing the Pooh stories and then exploiting their son to publicise them. Maybe that is unfair on her. Milne is also guilty through his own wilful ignorance. Eventually he realises what he is doing but not before the little boy is dragged from his childhood into the adult world with little regard for the impact it is having on him.
Ashdown Forest, inspiration of the 100 acre wood and all things Pooh
The themes aren’t unexpected, given this is pretty well known territory (though there is depth in how the film lets you understand the reasoning behind how it came about); what was well done was a form of reconciliation between father and son, or maybe of understanding at some level: when CR realised that many of his fellow servicemen adored his father’s books simply because they took them back to the safety of their childhood memories and relieved them from the horrors of war, even if only briefly, the film suggests that some of his anger dissipated.
In fact they remained estranged.
But the tweeness of the stories is where in effect we find the substance of Pullman’s criticism. That the stories do not prepare children for adulthood. That they aren’t what children want but rather are how adults perceive childhood. The return to that place of safety, of unbridled happiness.
And it’s true; adults want to preserve while children want to escape. But really, did I… did my children… ever begrudge being read to about Pooh and Piglet? Or Moley and Badger come to that? Of course not. So back off Pullman. That bear isn’t for baiting. Not on my watch. It may lack some historical accuracy but this a film to escape into, at least for a while.
Apparently there is a shortage of good vanilla at the moment which meant an absence of my usual at the gellateria opposite the East Dulwich Picturehouse – While there I noticed a new cheese shop had opened, a sure sign of excessive gentrification, next door, which I suppose I will have to trial. Back to the gelato;However the latte version was an acceptable alternative, if a little weak, flavour-wise. And reasonably priced considering the market hereabouts is all Tim and Tina cullottes and chia-infused organic cat food.
It’s another on my to watch list!
LikeLiked by 1 person
defo worth it
LikeLike
Hmmm… Interesting. But the writer is not the man, in many cases. Apparently
T.S. Elliot was a horrible person to be with, and I think in some ways so was Nabokov. It’s easy to be admirative if one loves the writing. In any case, Winnie is for younger children than Pullman’s books, so I don’t think there’s a necessity for comparison.
LikeLiked by 1 person
No, he could ahve stuck to his age group and left the little cuddles alone
LikeLike
On the other hand, I’ve been to talks by some writers where I really would have liked to meet them. They were really inspiring (Doris Lessing, Amos Oz, Julian Barnes and Margaret Atwood, especially)
LikeLiked by 1 person
yes, there are people out there you are just sure will be all they are cracked up to be
LikeLiked by 1 person
I do want to see this. As for Pullman’s comment about the Pooh stories not being what children want, I don’t know how he can be so sure. I think children, especially when they are still at an age when they enjoy being read to, take in just about everything with relish – from Grimm’s fairy stories to The Wind in the Willows; from Pooh to Paddington.
LikeLiked by 1 person
quite; maybe he was put up to it or misquoted but if true he deserves to be taken off several Christmas card lists
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s a shame. I loved his trilogy (as did my son) and I admired the way he spoke up for authors to be paid properly for appearing at book festivals and thought he was one of the good guys. Ah well, we’re all human, we’re all flawed!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yep he has a lot of good opinions. Maybe his haemorrhoids were playing up.
LikeLike
‘People don’t want this’ is a phrase used by people who actually mean ‘I don’t want this, and as I am in position to decide what people have, I will give them what I think they need.’
The phrase has been used by BBC executives about popular types of programme, that they don’t want to make, National Trust executives about country houses, theatre manages about traditional types of production, council ‘cultural officers’ about libraries etc.
So, whenever you hear the phrase, look out for a petty tyrant who thinks that people are stupid but won’t come out and say so.
LikeLiked by 3 people
how deeply philosophical… you been on the Earl grey again?
LikeLike
No, for philosophy I would suggest Pu Erh tea, a rare and interesting variety with a distinct smell of fish.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That could describe you…
LikeLike
So long and thanks for ???
LikeLiked by 1 person
soz
LikeLike
I have loved Pooh Bear all my life – though not the Disney version. The stories and simple drawings speak for themselves. All life is there. One year at a youth group summer camp in Australia one of the chaps read a chapter each breakfast time to 15 – 30 year age range. We all loved it. I don’t see why children should not have a cosy world in books – the same cosy world we parents and grandparents like to retreat to when we read to children.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Quite; back off our bear, Pullman!
LikeLike
Well, the CR stories may not have been what Pullman enjoyed when he was little, but a lot of us certainly did, and still do. The function of children’s stories isn’t necessarily to prepare them for life. Anyway, I haven’t read any of Pullman’s stuff, so yah boo to him!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Actually his stuff is pretty good, which is why I’m pissed at him. Still as one other commentator said the books arent the man.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I may never look at the Winnie the Pooh books the same way.
As I often write posts about my children, I do feel as if I am dancing on that fine line. On one hand, I want to respect their privacy and yet, on the other hand, I know their stories are the ones that are most relatable and because they are relatable, have the most impact.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m with you. Perhaps that’s why I focus on my dead parents since, with the best will in the world, they aren’t about to moan.
LikeLiked by 1 person
😀 😀 😀 chia-infused organic cat food
My kids LOVED all the Pooh books and I LOVED reading them and giving voice to the characters – and we can all still do our version of Eeyore when any occasion warrants it. I’ve read about the ruination of CR’s life due to the books and I’m not sure I want to see a film about it. (Perhaps his life would have been ‘ruined’ by his parents even had the books not been written.) I think Winnie the Pooh and all his pals down there in 100 Acre Wood have taken on their own lives exactly because of their personalities in their never-ending idyllic childhood and never changing stories. I was taken there once and admit to a feeling of disappointment that I didn’t see a little bear gambolling or a Kanga, Wol or Eeyore strolling by. Generations of children and parents have loved the books, generations more will continue to enjoy them I am sure (despite Disney effing it all up).
LikeLiked by 1 person
Quite. Hear hear. You hit the nail. Etc. I did pooh stick and the ashdown forest in late summer is still buzzing with idyllic vibes. Do try the film; it actually pretty good since it’s not about pooh but human frailty. Actually that probably is about Pooh if I think about it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I don’t think the Pooh books are all cosy and lovely. They may sem that way to children but, as you say, there’s human frailty and Eeeyore’s depression.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Yes eeyore is Everyman
LikeLiked by 2 people
Okay, you’ve convinced me …..
LikeLiked by 2 people
You are an easy win….
LikeLiked by 1 person
Very interesting. I didn’t know the history of the Winnie the Pooh books.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s quite cool to Pooh sticks on the actual bridge…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sad, sad I think I shall give it a miss!! 🌹
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh well it is worth a little watch, if you needed to fill a couple of hours
LikeLike
Maybe, I shall ponder it over the honey pot! The last film I saw was Blade Runner 2049, if you saw the first one and enjoyed it , it is brilliant. …
LikeLiked by 1 person
Review coming up…
LikeLike
Is that a question or are you doing one ? 😱 Because if you are asking me I have never done a film review …
LikeLiked by 1 person
one coming for the film review factory, South London Branch
LikeLike
Did you enjoy it I really did 💖
LikeLiked by 1 person
You’ll find out
LikeLike
Movies about writers have nothing unless the writer in question has some nastiness in his life. No movie (to my recollection) has ever been attempted about JRR Tolkien!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes now there’s a man with issues! I always loved the tortured life of CS Lewis. Does that make me cruel?
LikeLike
You put it perfectly with “It may lack some historical accuracy but this a film to escape into, at least for a while.”. I loved it.
LikeLike