Ed Fringe 2015 – a first review

2015-08-26 16.28.39

I’m back in Edinburgh for a few days at the Fringe.

So the headlines on days one and two: our crack review team bring you their thoughts.

Matthew Forde ‘Lets Get The Political Party Started

He is a political satirist who thinks the British political scene full of comic possibilities. His take is witty and painful. Ed Milliband is eviscerated as is Andy Burham and Liz Kendall but Jeremy Corbin, apart from being described as comic gold, is left alone. Is he a closet supporter or just praying Corbin wins? As he says, if Cameron resigns as he’s promised before 2020 and Boris, the bookies favourite wins. the idea of Boris v Jeremy couldn’t be scripted. Frightening really.

2015-08-26 11.39.54

The Vet

The Vet: ‘He was epic at accents’ ‘From someone politically naive it was educational’ ‘Great for quoting – eg Nigel Farage saying: Sometimes I think I’m too tolerant

2015-08-25 17.43.18


Garfunkel (the Vet’s bezzie) ‘even handed – he slated everyone’ ‘What’s wrong with having two kitchens?’

Dillie Keane – ex Fascinating Aida

A cabaret singer on her own, with a mix of old songs, both funny and touching. ‘I wish I’d been a lesbian’ and ‘Autumn Crocus’ were hilarious and poignant respectively. An easy hour but in truth the variety of FA was lost rather in this set.

Garfunkel: ‘She’s definitely a woman’

The Vet: ‘Kinky old bird’ ‘Best song was about ‘Pam’

Garfunkel: ‘Who’s Pam?’

The Vet: ‘The one who left her bra behind.’

Garfunkel: ‘Not the one with the crocuses?’

Pajama Men: two men three musketeers

Two guys in pajamas playing 20 characters as they follow D’Artagnan from his early life to saving the Queen from disgrace – the fat cardinal was an exceptionally rounded characterisation.

The Vet: ‘I never really understood what was happening but captivating’ ‘An improvement on South Park’

Garfunkel: ‘Hilarious: accidents will happen’ ‘So many different characters’ ‘My stitches came out’

The Vet. ‘Did you see Pam?’

Falsetto Scottish Sock Puppet Show and the Minging Detective

One man, two socks, many detectives. If you’re British and over 50 it was very funny, if you’re not it was just two socks doing silly voies…. Lots of memories of cop shows down the years. Probably funnier if we hadn’t already seen four shows in six hours.

The Vet ‘Eh?’ ‘I laughed but I’m not sure why.’ ‘Dad needs to remember his meds.’

Garfunkel. ‘I’ll ask my dad.’

The Vet: ‘He kept asking about Pam. Did you hear him?’

Garfunkel: ‘My dad does that.’

The Vet: ‘Ask about Pam?’

Garfunkel: ‘Forget his meds.’

Bite Sized Breakfast

Five Ten Minute Plays and a croissant and strawberry. These comprised:

A sketch where the audience chose the twists – a nice idea that lacked a follow through.

A red button on a table, guarded by a man – a woman wants to press it so they discuss freedom of action against team work, control against anarchy – too worthy.

A composer loves the cellist who supports his writing and the talented violinist who plays his concerto. He can’t decide who he loves most and we never find out. He’s just a rat. Disappointing.

A doctor examines a patient: his associate joins the examination and we find she and the patient are new lovers – comedy ensues but the jokes are a bit too obvious.

I forget the last play. Still two more rotations to see tomorrow and Friday so maybe it will perk up.

The Vet. ‘I almost sympathised with the rat.’ ‘I liked being able to choose the stories’. ‘The croissant was fresh. I got three strawberries’

Garfunkel. ‘The composer was a rat. Bast***.’ ‘How did you get the extra strawberries?’

The Vet: ‘I asked Pam.’


A young man with an Anglo Indian heritage explores the labels we put on people. Thought provoking and unsettling. We are all victims of stereotyping and hypocrisy. Most telling was a cartoon: a naval boat is alongside a refugee boat full of people heading across the Med from North Africa to Europe. The sailor shouts ‘where are you from?’ The refugees shout back ‘Earth’. As the actor pointed out with some neat references, the current lingua has ‘immigrant’ = bad , ‘migrant’ = good. Loved this even if he stuck a label with ‘caveman’ on my T shirt.

The Vet. ‘Oh god he was so fit’ ‘Dad is a bit of a caveman’

Garfunkel. ‘Gerrof. I lusted first. He sounded good too.’ ‘I think Pam got the label with ‘friend’ on it, though.’

The Vet: ‘Grrrr’

Fully Committed with Marcus Brigstock.

Well known comedian does a one man play about working as the Booker at a top NY restaurant. As this followed on from a very serious hour making us very uncomfortable at the cartoon Indian accents we hear, the plethora of voices and accents he uses grated for a while. That said, this is undoubtedly a tour de force, utterly exhausting to play. The Textiliste gave it a sour lemon but I’d say a nearly ripe mango.

Garfunkel. ‘Soooooo good. The camp as Christmas accents were a delight.’

The Vet. ‘Eh?’ ‘Can we have another strawberry please?’

Me: ‘Nothing about Pam?’

Them; ‘Daaaad! Geofffffff! Perleaseee’

Bedsocks and Secrets

Bloody hell. Ten minutes in and I had experienced the most visceral and uncomfortable ten minutes of theatre in my life. In a room the size of our fridge we watched as two indifferent nursing home staff strip washed an elderly patent suffering with dementia before dressing her and leaving her with the son she no longer recognises. In a touching scene she meets her old self and that old self, a young woman is seen taking the elderly woman’s place for a while. After 20 minutes I was exhausted. Then we followed her son into a car with no wheels where he and a young woman, supposedly about 16 to the son’s 50 plus talk about loneliness, secrets and sex. It makes little, if any, sense. The acting at the outset is exceptional, at the end execrable. For different reasons the whole hour was seat squirmingly uncomfortable.

The Vet: ‘Bloody hell. Don’t let mum choose again’

Garfunkel: ‘I think, all things considered, I preferred Pam.’

Our hand picked team will be back later.


About TanGental

My name is Geoff Le Pard. Once I was a lawyer; now I am a writer. I've published several books: a four book series following Harry Spittle as he grows from hapless student to hapless partner in a London law firm; four others in different genres; a book of poetry; four anthologies of short fiction; and a memoir of my mother. I have several more in the pipeline. I have been blogging regularly since 2014, on topic as diverse as: poetry based on famous poems; memories from my life; my garden; my dog; a whole variety of short fiction; my attempts at baking and food; travel and the consequent disasters; theatre, film and book reviews; and the occasional thought piece. Mostly it is whatever takes my fancy. I avoid politics, mostly, and religion, always. I don't mean to upset anyone but if I do, well, sorry and I suggest you go elsewhere. These are my thoughts and no one else is to blame. If you want to nab anything I post, please acknowledge where it came from.
This entry was posted in edinburgh, Edinburgh Fringe, miscellany and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

16 Responses to Ed Fringe 2015 – a first review

  1. willowdot21 says:

    Excellent I almost feel like I was there! As for Pam in leu of yesterday being dog day


  2. Yvonne says:

    Goodness, Geoff! I live in Edinburgh and have not been to a quarter of the shows you have! But I think that’s what happens. We went to more when we visited before we lived here.
    If you get a chance I recommend Shakespeare for Breakfast, which I haven’t been to this year, but the family have and it’s always funny. (And you get croissants, but no strawberries!) Austentatious was really good too.

    Liked by 1 person

    • TanGental says:

      We had Austentatious on the list but it clashed! Yes we do the touristy bit rather with six shows a day and then collapse! Marvellous city, this!


  3. noelleg44 says:

    Sounds like great fun! What a place for comedy and, let us say, unusual productions! I loved your pictures of Edinburgh – haven’t been there for many years, but visiting was always a treat.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. roweeee says:

    Geoff, sounds like the lucky dip analogy applies to these acts. Bad or good, I like to think of them as potential inspiration in some way. Looks like you had great company though.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. jan says:

    Sounds like a hoot! Lovely young traveling companions you have!


  6. You know, Geoff, I’ve never yet made it to the Fringe. Strangely, in spite of previous good intentions, I’ve not felt anything like as inspired to go as you have made me now.

    Liked by 1 person

    • TanGental says:

      I put it off for many years, mostly because of kids and limited holidays, but once they reached an age where they would either holiday alone or go off with friends we went and it is fantastic. So much so that in the last year each child has come with us and is now committed.

      Liked by 1 person

  7. Ali Isaac says:

    Sounds like a packed weekend!

    Liked by 1 person

  8. Great photos! And I’m really hoping that dialogue is for real. I think the bits you included between your daughter and her friend might be funnier than the shows. Though I’ve never been to the Fringe. *sticks tongue out*

    I do love the answer “Earth!” to the question “Where are you from?” Reminds me of a horrible article (I won’t even give it courtesy by mentioning where it was from) I just read. Part of it (the bloody thing couldn’t seem to make up its mind what it was about) was about how people are too sensitive about people asking them (particularly Asian American — they were born in America) “Where were you born?” Because, um, it’s silly people would get upset about that. O_o And, except in context, who asks that? Sorry. Yes, great photos.

    Liked by 1 person

    • TanGental says:

      I saw a Jon Stewart diatribe on that not so long ago. He’s going to be missed, at least by me! I recently found John Oliver on the net. Even if he’s a Brummie he’s very perceptive.

      Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.